The Iliad

Poetry | Homer

Critically comment on the duel between Paris and Menelaus.

Premium

Critically comment on the duel between Paris and Menelaus NU Homer c - BCE presents many battles and duels in his epic The Iliad BCE The duel between Paris and Menelaus is very important It was meant to end the war but it shows both fate and trickery The Challenge The war begins because Paris takes Helen from Menelaus To avoid more blood both sides agree on a duel Paris first offers to fight in single combat Menelaus accepts the challenge with strong anger Both sides agree that the winner will keep Helen This shows hope for peace Weakness of Paris Paris proves weak in the duel with Menelaus Menelaus is stronger and nearly kills him Paris is saved only by the goddess Aphrodite She takes him away from danger This shows Paris as cowardly and dependent on divine help Failure of The Oath The Greeks and Trojans had sworn

an oath They promised to accept the result of the duel But when Paris is rescued the oath is broken Fighting begins again with more cruelty This shows weakness of human promises Role of the Gods The duel shows how gods control human fate Aphrodite saves Paris and takes him to Helen This divine act makes the duel useless It also proves how much the gods interfere in war To conclusion The duel between Paris and Menelaus shows human weakness and divine control Paris fails as a hero but the gods protect him Homer uses the duel to reveal both fate and human dishonor

Continue Reading

Sign in and subscribe to unlock the full content