riendship.
Division in Chandrapore (Indian vs British): Chandrapore is divided. The Indian town is poor. Forster writes,
“The inhabitants of mud moving.”
The civil station is neat. Aziz, Hamidullah, and Mahmoud Ali live in the bazaar. Ronny Heaslop, Mr. Turton, Mrs. Turton, Major Callendar, and Mrs. Callendar live on the hill. They do not mix. Mrs. Moore and Adela Quested wish to see the “real India.” But invisible walls exist. This division is the first sign of cultural conflict.
The Bridge Party and the Trial (Indian vs British): Mr. Turton is the Collector of Chandrapore. He arranges a Bridge Party. He says it will join East and West. Aziz, Hamidullah, Mahmoud Ali, and Nawab Bahadur attend. Mrs. Turton and Mrs. Callendar are asked to welcome purdah women. But the party fails. Indians stand on one side. English stands the other. Mrs. Moore and Adela Quested sincerely try to talk. Adela’s wish to see the real India. But the City Magistrate, Ronny Heaslop, mocks. He says,
“The educated Indians will be no good to us if there’s a row... they don’t matter”.
This shows arrogance. The clash grows in the trial. Adela falsely accuses Aziz. The English community unites against him. Ronny, Turton, Mrs. Turton, Callendar, and Mrs. Callendar demand punishment. Only Fielding supports him. Indians like Hamidullah and Mahmoud Ali defend him. The court becomes a battlefield of cultures.
The Marabar Caves – Symbol of Misunderstanding: The caves show confusion. Inside, the echo destroys meaning. Forster writes,
“The echo in a Marabar cave is entirely devoid of distinction… all produce ‘boum’.”
Adela feels fear. She imagines Aziz attacked her. Aziz is arrested. Mrs. Moore also feels broken. The caves stand for the failure of communication. They destroy trust between the English and the Indians. They break Mrs. Moore’s spirit. They ruin Aziz’s hope. The caves are the symbol of the East–West conflict.
Hindu vs Muslim Conflict: Forster also shows conflict inside India. Dr. Aziz feels closer to other Muslims like Hamidullah and Mahmoud Ali. Professor Godbole is Hindu. He is calm, mystical, and detached. Aziz often mocks Hindus as unreliable. He cannot understand Godbole’s spirituality. In Mau, Hindus celebrate Krishna’s festival. Godbole joins with joy. Aziz feels out of place as a Muslim. This shows Hindus and Muslims do not fully unite. India itself is divided by culture.
Collapse of Friendship: At first, friendship looks possible. Aziz likes Mrs. Moore. She says in the mosque,
“God is here.”
He respects her. Fielding also trusts Aziz. He says to Adela,
“Try seeing Indians.”
But the caves and the trial ruin it. Adela is disgraced. Aziz loses faith. He says India and England cannot be friends till India is free. At the end, Aziz and Fielding ride together, but nature answers,
“No, not yet… No, not there.”
The clash of cultures remains. Friendship must wait for freedom.
Forster shows “A Passage to India” as a novel of cultural clash. The main conflict is between the Indians and the British. The hidden conflict is between Hindus and Muslims. Aziz, Mrs. Moore, Adela, Fielding, Ronny, Turton, Callendar, Hamidullah, Mahmoud Ali, and Godbole all play roles. Forster’s message is clear: under the Raj, cultures clash, not unite.
Continue Reading
Subscribe to access the full content
Upgrade to Premium