Desire Under the Elms

Drama | Eugene O'Neill

How does O'Neill react to the philosophy of Puritanism? Discuss it in reference to the play “Desire Under the Elms”.

Premium

How does O'Neill react to the philosophy of Puritanism? Discuss it in reference to the play “Desire Under the Elms”. [2017]  

Eugene O’Neill (1888–1953), in his play Desire Under the Elms (1924), reacts strongly to the strict philosophy of Puritanism. The Puritans believed in hard work, sin, and punishment. They denied joy and passion in life. In the play, O’Neill shows how this belief destroys human happiness. Ephraim Cabot follows the Puritan code blindly, and his life becomes full of loneliness and pain. O’Neill rejects Puritan hardness and praises natural human desires and emotions as essential for life. 

Puritan Faith and Harsh Discipline: Cabot represents the Puritan spirit in the play. He believes in hard work and suffering as ways to please God. He says, 

“God’s hard, not easy.” 

pan style="font-weight: 400;">This shows his belief that life must be full of pain. He forces his sons to work day and night on the stony farm. His heart is full of pride, not love. O’Neill uses Cabot to criticize the Puritan idea that faith means rejecting joy. He shows that such belief makes life dry and cruel.

Hard Work and Lack of Humanity: The Puritan faith values work more than feelings. Cabot thinks his land is sacred because he earned it with sweat and pain. But his love for the farm becomes greed. He forgets his family’s needs. His wives die in sorrow, and his sons hate him. O’Neill shows that work without love brings emptiness. The stones on the land become symbols of Cabot’s hard heart and the cold Puritan spirit.

Suppression of Desire and Joy: Puritanism teaches people to control emotions and desires. But O’Neill believes that natural desires are part of human life. Eben and Abbie’s love is sinful by Puritan law, yet it is full of life. Abbie says, 

“Can’t ye see it’s got t’ be that an’ more—much more—fur me t’ be happy?”

Her words express passion and longing. O’Neill suggests that denying such feelings leads to tragedy. The play shows how love, when suppressed, turns into guilt and destruction.

Conflict Between Religion and Nature: O’Neill contrasts Cabot’s religion with the natural world around him. The elm trees, stones, and farmhouse reflect human emotion. The elms are described as 

“They brood oppressively over the house.” 

They symbolize nature’s power over human pride. Cabot sees God as a punishing ruler, but O’Neill presents nature as a living force. He believes that nature, not strict religion, guides true human feeling. Through this, O’Neill rejects Puritan coldness and supports natural emotion and freedom.

Loneliness and Moral Failure: Ultimately, Cabot feels alone and broken. His Puritan belief gives him no comfort. He says sadly, 

“God’s lonesome, hain’t He? God’s hard an’ lonesome.” 

His life proves that faith without love is empty. His sons leave him, and his wife betrays him. O’Neill shows that strict Puritan ideals destroy relationships and happiness. Cabot’s loneliness becomes the punishment for his pride and blindness. The play ends with silence under the dark elms—symbols of sorrow and lost hope.

To sum up, O’Neill clearly rejects Puritanism. Through Cabot, he shows that faith without love becomes cruelty. Puritan ideals of work, sin, and punishment bring only loneliness and guilt. O’Neill believes that true life lies in emotion, passion, and nature. His reaction to Puritanism is a defense of human desire and freedom against cold, lifeless faith and moral pride.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to access the full content

Upgrade to Premium