I Taste a Liquor Never Brewed

Poetry | Emily Dickinson

Is Emily Dickinson a romantic poet or a modern poet?

Premium

Is Emily Dickinson a romantic poet or a modern poet? Elucidate with reference to her poem you have read.

Emily Dickinson (1830-1886) is a very special poet because she stands between two ages: the Romantic age and the Modern age. She writes about nature, death, the soul, and personal feelings like a Romantic poet. But she also uses very unusual images, short lines, broken grammar, and very bold ideas, which look completely modern. So, she becomes a bridge between Romanticism and Modernism. Let us take a closer look at Dickinson's poems below to elucidate.

 

Love for Nature and Imagination: Dickinson’s love for nature and imagination shows her Romantic side strongly. In “I Taste a Liquor Never Brewed” (1861), she celebrates the beauty of nature. Instead of drinking real wine, she becomes drunk on “Air” and “Dew.” She writes:

 

“Inebriate of Air--am I--

And Debauchee of Dew–”<

/b>

 

This is a classic Romantic idea. Romantic poets believed that nature is the source of happiness for the soul. She moves through “endless summer days” and enjoys the natural world. She even imagines “Seraphs” (angels) and “Saints” watching her joy. This shows a powerful imagination, which is also a Romantic quality. Romantic poets loved to escape into nature, and Dickinson uses nature to show freedom, joy, and innocence.

 

Death, Soul, and Eternity: Romantic poets often explored big mysteries like death and the soul. In “Because I Could Not Stop for Death” (1890), Dickinson treats Death as a polite gentleman. Death takes her on a peaceful carriage ride. She writes:

 

“Because I could not stop for Death –

He kindly stopped for me –”

 

This calm, emotional treatment of death is very Romantic.

 

On their journey, she passes the school, the fields (Gazing Grain), and the setting sun. This journey becomes the journey of life itself. We can see life’s beginning and the end. The school, where the children are playing, stands for the early ages of childhood. The green fields stand for the vitality of the youth. The setting sun represents the end of life. Dickinson says the horses are going towards “Eternity.” This shows her Romantic interest in the afterlife. The mood is quiet, slow, and thoughtful, exactly like the deeper emotions Romantic poets loved to explore.

 

Psychological Exploration and Inner Pain: Even though Dickinson has Romantic elements, she is also deeply modern. Because she goes inside the human mind. In “I Felt a Funeral, in My Brain” (written in 1861), she shows the breaking of the mind in a very unusual way. She imagines her thoughts as mourners walking inside her head.

 

“I felt a Funeral, in my Brain,

And Mourners to and fro

Kept treading - treading…”

 

The “Drum” beating feels like mental pressure. The “Plank in Reason” breaks, and she falls down into confusion. It means she has lost her sense of reason.

 

This poem is not about nature or beauty. It is about psychological suffering and mental collapse. These are modern themes. Modern poets often wrote about the mind, fear, anxiety, and the feeling of being lost in the world. Dickinson shows all of this long before modern poetry officially began.

 

Modern Style—Short Lines, Dashes, Strange Images: Dickinson’s technique is also modern. She uses unusual punctuation, random capital letters, and sudden images. For example, in “Because I Could Not Stop for Death,” she writes short, calm lines that hide big meanings. For example:

 

“Since then – 'tis Centuries – and yet

Feels shorter than the Day”

 

Here, Dickinson is talking about big ideas like the afterlife and eternity. This technique breaks traditional rules. Romantic poets often wrote smooth, long lines. Dickinson uses sharp, quick, surprising lines. This is exactly what modern poets later started to do.

 

A Bridge Between Romanticism and Modernism: So, Dickinson is both Romantic and Modern. She writes about nature, the soul, eternity, deep emotions, and imagination. These are Romantic themes. But she also writes about mental struggle and inner loneliness. These are modern themes. Her style also mixes both worlds: simple but powerful; emotional but also mysterious; natural but also psychological.

 

In fine, Emily Dickinson cannot be placed fully in one group. She has the heart of a Romantic poet, but she also has the voice and style of a modern poet. We clearly see that Dickinson stands between two ages. She connects the Romantic world with the coming Modern world. It makes her one of the most unique poets in English literature.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to access the full content

Upgrade to Premium