A Passage to India

Novel | E. M. Forster

Discuss the relationship between Adela and Dr. Aziz in the novel A Passage to India.

Premium

Discuss the

relationship between Adela and Dr. Aziz in the novel A Passage to India.

M. Forster’s (1879-1970) novel A Passage to India (1924) is about friendship and misunderstanding between the British and the Indians during British rule. The relationship between Adela Quested and Dr. Aziz is one of the most important parts of the story. Their friendship begins with hope but ends in confusion and pain. Through their relationship, Forster shows the barriers between two cultures.

A Meeting Full of Curiosity and Kindness: Adela comes to India with Mrs. Moore to see if she should marry Ronny Heaslop, the city magistrate of Chandrapore. She is curious about the “real India.” She says:

“I want to see the real India.”

She wants to meet Indians freely, not just through British parties. Dr. Aziz, a young Muslim doctor, is kind, lively, and emotional. He meets Mrs. Moore by chance in a mosque. Their friendly talk opens his heart. When Adela meets Aziz later, she also feels friendly and simple toward him. She says she wants to see the “true India,” and Aziz feels happy that an English lady wants to understand his country. Their first meetings show hope for friendship and understanding between East and West.

The Picnic to the Marabar Caves: The turning point in their relationship happens during the picnic to the Marabar Caves. Aziz arranges this trip to please Adela and Mrs. Moore. He works very hard to make everything perfect. He hires servants and brings food. He even arranges elephants for the guests. At first, the trip goes well. Adela and Aziz talk about his family, marriage, and Indian life. But inside the caves, something strange happens. The echo inside the cave confuses and frightens Adela. She suddenly feels lost. She thinks Aziz has attacked her. She runs out in shock and confusion. The misunderstanding in the cave becomes a picture of how little the British really understand India or its people. Aziz, unaware of what happened, goes to look for her. He later finds himself accused of a terrible crime.

The False Accusation and Its Pain: The news of Adela’s accusation spreads quickly. The British community becomes angry and hateful toward Indians. Aziz is arrested. All his English friends turn against him, except Mr. Fielding, the principal of the college. For Aziz, this moment destroys all trust he had in the British. He feels deeply hurt because he treated Adela with respect. His dream of friendship between races breaks. Adela, on the other hand, slowly realizes her mistake. She sees that she was confused by fear, heat, and the strange echo of the cave. The misunderstanding becomes a symbol of the failure of East-West friendship.

Forgiveness and Understanding: During the trial, Adela bravely tells the truth that Aziz did not attack her. The court becomes silent. Aziz is set free. Adela’s honesty surprises everyone. Though Aziz forgives her, he cannot forget his pain. He feels that no real friendship can exist between the ruler and the ruled. However, Adela’s action also shows moral courage. She stands against her own people to save an innocent man. Adela and Aziz’s relationship turns from friendship to a distant understanding.

The End of Their Friendship: After the trial, Adela leaves India. She realizes she cannot marry Ronny and returns to England. Aziz also decides to live far from the British. He moves to Mau and dreams of a free India. When he later meets Fielding again, he speaks bitterly about the past. The incident with Adela remains in his memory as proof that real friendship between an English person and an Indian is impossible under British rule. We understand this when Aziz tells Fielding:

“Drive every blasted Englishman into the sea, and then ... you and I shall be friends.”

 The novel tells us that friendship must wait until India is free.

In conclusion, the relationship between Adela and Dr. Aziz begins with curiosity and respect but ends in fear and misunderstanding. Their story shows how differences in race, culture, and power destroy human connection. Adela’s mistake and Aziz’s pain show the deep division between East and West. Forster uses their friendship to show that true understanding can exist only in a world of equality and freedom.

Continue Reading

Subscribe to access the full content

Upgrade to Premium