A Tale of Two Cities

Novel | Charles Dickens

Tale of Two Cities a historical novel? Give reasons for your answer

Premium

Would you call Dickens’ “A Tale of Two Cities a historical novel?” Give reasons for your answer. [NU: 2013, 15, 17, 19, 22] ★★★

Or. Evaluate Dickens’ “A Tale of Two Cities” as a historical novel. 

Charles Dickens (1812–1870) wrote “A Tale of Two Cities” in 1859. The novel is set between 1775 and 1794. It was the time of the French Revolution. The author blends real historical facts with fictional characters and personal stories. Through this method, he shows how great historical events influence or

dinary people’s lives. For this reason, the book can rightly be called a historical novel.

Real Historical Events: The French Revolution is at the center of the story. Dickens shows events like the storming of the Bastille (1789). He also describes the burning of the Evrémonde château in Book Two, Chapter XXIII. The September Massacres of 1792 are recalled, where over 1,100 prisoners were killed. These real events create the background of the story. Through them, Dickens shows the fall of the aristocracy and the rise of mob violence.

Dickens’ Source and Aim: Dickens read Thomas Carlyle’s The French Revolution as his main source. Carlyle’s book gave him details of mobs, tribunals, and the Terror. Dickens wanted not just facts but moral lessons. He used history to show love, sacrifice, and human struggle. So, the novel is more a historical romance than a strict history.

Social Conditions: The novel shows the huge gap between the rich and the poor. The Marquis runs over a child with his carriage and gives a coin as payment. He says, 

“Repression is the only lasting philosophy.” 

This cruelty explains why the poor hated the nobles. In Book One, Chapter V, the wine-cask breaks in Saint Antoine. People drink the wine from the street. Dickens uses this to foreshadow bloodshed in the Revolution.

Powerful Symbols of History: The guillotine is the main symbol. Dickens calls it the “National Razor.” He even writes: 

“It superseded the Cross.” (Book Three, Chapter IV). 

This shows how the guillotine became a new religion of death. In Book Three, Chapter II, Dickens shows the Grindstone scene. The mob sharpens weapons at midnight in a hellish picture. 

Historical Settings: The novel moves between London and Paris. London is calm and peaceful. Paris is violent and full of unrest. In the Defarges’ wine shop, revolutionaries meet and plan. On the street, we see signs: 

“Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, or Death.” 

These settings show the two cities as opposites, safety versus terror.

Historical Figures through Characters: Dickens avoids real leaders like Robespierre or Danton. Instead, he shows how ordinary people lived history. Dr. Manette suffers as a prisoner in the Bastille. Lucie is the “golden thread” who gives him new life. Madame Defarge represents the revenge and bitterness of the oppressed. She says: 

“Is it likely that the trouble of one wife and mother would be much to us now?” 

Her cold heart shows how private pain turned into national revenge.

Limitations of Historical Accuracy: Dickens takes some liberties with dates and details. He shows events more for drama than accuracy. But his goal was not a textbook. His aim was to show moral truth in history. So the novel belongs to the Scott tradition of historical fiction.

In conclusion, “A Tale of Two Cities” is a true historical novel. It mixes real events, social conditions, and symbols with touching human stories. Dickens uses the Revolution to teach lessons of justice, sacrifice, and love. Through Dr. Manette, Madame Defarge, and Sydney Carton, we see how history changes lives. 

Continue Reading

Subscribe to access the full content

Upgrade to Premium
From this writer
C
Charles Dickens
Literary Writer
More Topics