The Scarlet Letter

Novel | Nathaniel Hawthorne

Comment on the use of irony in “The Scarlet Letter”

Premium

Comment on the use of irony in The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne in The Scarlet Letter uses irony to deepen the moral and emotional effect of his story Irony means a contrast between what appears to be true and what actually is true Hawthorne uses this device to show the hypocrisy of Puritan society and the weakness of human nature Through the characters of Hester Dimmesdale and Chillingworth he reveals the ironic gap between appearance and reality purity and sin punishment and forgiveness Public Shame And Hidden Sin The greatest irony lies in the contrast between Hester s open shame and Dimmesdale s secret guilt Hester is punished in public yet she becomes stronger and purer Dimmesdale hides his sin and becomes weak and sick An unnamed woman says The Reverend Master Dimmesdale takes it very grievously to his heart The irony is clear because Dimmesdale himself is the sinner

His holy image hides his crime Hawthorne uses this irony to expose human hypocrisy and weakness The Letter as Punishment and Glory The scarlet letter A is meant to bring shame but it becomes a symbol of honour People first read it as Adulteress but later it seems to mean Able The narrator says It may serve to symbolize some sweet moral blossom The letter once a mark of sin turns into a lesson of strength and sympathy Ironically what society means for punishment becomes a path to moral growth Hester s pain brings beauty and goodness to others Thus the symbol defeats its cruel purpose Chillingworth s Evil Purpose Chillingworth s revenge also carries deep irony He hides his true identity and pretends to be a healer but he becomes the real destroyer Dimmesdale says He has violated in cold blood the sanctity of a human heart The physician who should heal actually kills the soul of another man His desire to punish turns him into a greater sinner than Hester or Dimmesdale Hawthorne shows the irony of intellect without love It proves that cruelty dressed as care becomes the darkest form of sin Dimmesdale s Public Honour Dimmesdale is praised as a holy man but he knows his own guilt People admire him for his saintly words yet his heart burns with shame He even stands on the scaffold at night to punish himself In the end when he confesses the people are shocked This irony highlights the dual nature of human existence One face for the world and another for the soul Hawthorne employs this irony to convey that truth rather than appearance brings peace and redemption The Final Moral Irony Ultimately the story itself becomes a poignant irony of life Hester s sorrow gives peace while Dimmesdale s honor brings death The narrator s final moral says Be true Be true Be true The moral lesson is clear hiding sin brings suffering Ironically Hester s public shame saves her soul while Dimmesdale s secret destroys his life This irony completes the novel s tragic beauty and moral power To sum up Hawthorne fills The Scarlet Letter with rich and touching irony The story contrasts outer appearance with inner truth Every major character lives through ironic suffering Hester through shame Dimmesdale through guilt and Chillingworth through revenge These ironies expose the moral blindness of society and the weakness of human nature Through irony Hawthorne turns sin and sorrow into a timeless moral revelation

Continue Reading

Sign in and subscribe to unlock the full content

From this writer
N
Nathaniel Hawthorne
Literary Writer